Wait...some Muslims ARE violent, yet the FBI wants nothing to do with material that points that out. Some Christians are violent, some Buddhists are violent and some Mennonites are violent. Is the FBI purging their training materials of those groups as well?
By ignoring the truth as to Islamic hegemony, the FBI strangles it's ability to understand the doctrine behind the attacks. It is easier to dismiss these attacks as so much misunderstanding, rather than listening to those doing the attacking. Willful blindness is the new norm, and that will get us killed. The FBI is successful in thwarting jihad attacks in spite of itself, not because of itself.
From WIRED Feb 15 by Spencer Ackerman
By ignoring the truth as to Islamic hegemony, the FBI strangles it's ability to understand the doctrine behind the attacks. It is easier to dismiss these attacks as so much misunderstanding, rather than listening to those doing the attacking. Willful blindness is the new norm, and that will get us killed. The FBI is successful in thwarting jihad attacks in spite of itself, not because of itself.
From WIRED Feb 15 by Spencer Ackerman
FBI Purges Hundreds of Terrorism Documents in Islamophobia Probe
An internal FBI investigation into its counterterrorism training has purged hundreds of bureau documents of instructional material about Muslims, some of which characterized them as prone to violence or terrorism.
The bureau disclosed initial findings from its months-long review during a meeting at FBI headquarters on Wednesday with several Arab and Muslim advocacy groups, attended by Director Robert Mueller. So far, the inquiry has uncovered and purged over 700 pages of documentation from approximately 300 presentations given to agents since 9/11 — some of which were similar to briefings published by Danger Room last year describing “mainstream” Muslims as “violent.” And more disclosures may be forthcoming, as the FBI continues its inquiry and responds to Freedom of Information Act requests for the documents themselves.
FBI spokesman Christopher Allen confirms to Danger Room that the bureau found some of the documents to be objectionable because they were inaccurate or over-broad, others because they were offensive. Allen explains that the documents represent “less than 1 percent” of over 160,000 documents reviewed by the inquiry, which was prompted by a Danger Room investigation in September. The FBI purged documents according to four criteria: “factual errors”; “poor taste”; employment of “stereotypes” about Arabs or Muslims; or presenting information that “lacked precision.”
Who decided the criteria to make the judgments? What were these factual errors? What exactly was in poor taste? How much precision was lacking, and why?
Danger Room uncovered several such documents in the fall, including some instructing FBI counterterrorism agents that “mainstream” Muslims sympathized with terrorists; that the Prophet Mohammed was a “cult” leader; and that the more “devout” a Muslim was, the more likely he would be to commit a violent act. Some documents even purported to graph the correlation. The FBI initially said the instruction occurred “one time only.” But when Danger Room uncovered additional anti-Islam materials — in briefings that compared Islam to the Death Star; in books on the shelves of the FBI training library at Quantico; and in pages hosted on internal FBI websites — the bureau began an extensive internal review.
Salam al-Marayati, the executive director of the Muslim Public Affairs Council, attended the FBI meeting. He came away worried that the volume of anti-Muslim training documents hands al-Qaida an unnecessary win.
Ahh, now I see the problem. See more on Marayati here.
“People will report criminal activity to the authorities, that’s been proven time and again,” Marayati tells Danger Room. “But if we are giving propaganda to al-Qaida, resuscitating this dying ideology that al-Qaida is promoting, by continually exposing anti-Muslim propaganda published by the government, that undermines our pluralism, which is the best defense against any transnational ideological threat.”
Others think that the FBI can’t stop at purging internal documents. “It’s a bit hard to avoid the conclusion there isn’t a problem of culture in the [FBI] training division,” says Maya Berry, executive director of the Arab-American Institute, whose subordinates also attended the meeting. “It’s one that appears to have some built-in biases when it comes to the Arab-American and Muslim-American communities.” Allen declined to respond.
Read it all
No comments:
Post a Comment